Results of the heuristic competition for problem class SPG (8 threads)

Althaus-Blumenstock fscipjack fscipjackspx hedgekiller mozartballs mozartduet polito staynerd
Instance Primal Bound Primal Integral Time Primal Bound Primal Integral Time Primal Bound Primal Integral Time Primal Bound Primal Integral Time Primal Bound Primal Integral Time Primal Bound Primal Integral Time Primal Bound Primal Integral Time Primal Bound Primal Integral Time
Formula 1 15.5 32.0 41.4 27.5 39.9 21.5 150.9 155.2 144.5 142.8 149.8 142.2 85.3 78.0 152.5 180.8
Average 50554.0 776.7 6820.7 20109.9 172.4 6312.8 20144.5 192.2 6783.1 19911.3 9.5 3177.4 19915.9 8.9 3117.3 19904.7 8.5 3218.6 20305.1 75.1 3280.5 19913.8 6.8 3435.4
d18-p 223.0 0.0 1210.0 223.0 5.2 9.7 223.0 5.0 9.8 223.0 0.4 5.0 223.0 0.4 4.7 223.0 0.4 5.0 224.0 34.7 34.5 223.0 0.4 4.9
e18-p 24977.0 7037.4 7201.0 564.0 43.9 7288.3 564.0 41.8 6289.2 564.0 3.2 194.0 564.0 2.1 341.7 564.0 3.3 187.9 565.0 45.9 7200.3 564.0 2.1 293.6
i640-211-p 12025.0 24.6 7201.0 11991.0 163.7 57048.0 11991.0 199.9 56026.0 12021.0 24.2 7202.0 11984.0 9.2 5138.4 11984.0 8.5 7201.3 11984.0 7.5 7200.0 11984.0 0.4 3083.3
i640-314-p 35661.0 26.1 7201.0 35612.0 94.1 57057.4 35604.0 184.7 56369.5 35550.0 5.6 7201.4 35648.0 30.8 5314.8 35532.0 2.9 7201.1 35546.0 6.5 7200.0 35543.0 4.8 7200.1
i640-341-p 32389.0 77.2 7201.0 32128.0 30.7 52048.3 32118.0 34.6 44924.7 32110.0 16.3 7202.7 32106.0 15.9 7202.5 32115.0 17.3 7202.0 32114.0 17.9 7200.1 32113.0 17.4 7200.8
fnl4461fst-p 459882.0 4342.3 7201.0 -- 7200.0 7211.9 -- 7200.0 7216.7 182748.0 9.8 7240.0 182599.0 7.6 7236.1 182729.0 8.3 7294.7 193364.0 438.9 7200.4 182735.0 8.6 7200.9
world666-p 12453462.0 7129.2 7204.0 122467.0 3.1 13.7 122467.0 3.2 29.9 122467.0 3.8 3823.0 122467.0 7.6 3802.0 122467.0 4.0 3810.2 131207.0 493.8 7200.1 122467.0 3.1 7205.3
alue7080-p 383286.0 6025.7 7203.0 -- 7200.0 7234.2 -- 7200.0 7209.7 62612.0 12.7 7235.0 62695.0 21.6 7230.0 62627.0 14.1 7238.9 67871.0 573.5 7201.1 62594.0 10.5 7202.8
alut2625-p 451526.0 6634.4 7202.0 35795.0 2228.3 7220.4 35757.0 2200.6 7211.3 35688.0 47.2 7228.2 35791.0 65.3 7221.8 35618.0 32.1 7228.3 41395.0 1069.3 7200.1 35607.0 30.8 7203.0
es10000fst01-p 1442738340.0 3624.0 8092.0 -- 7200.0 7365.9 -- 7200.0 7365.9 716830388.0 3.4 7352.7 716693301.0 3.2 7323.0 716877244.0 3.8 7344.2 764427342.0 462.2 7200.2 716866079.0 3.7 7201.6
lin36-p -- 7200.0 7200.0 56504.0 684.7 7224.3 56644.0 711.3 7218.9 55827.0 31.8 7209.7 56208.0 77.8 7209.0 55907.0 42.6 7210.9 64841.0 1089.3 7200.5 55848.0 34.5 7212.7
lin37-p 2953338.0 6957.3 7202.0 100374.0 648.1 7222.2 100352.0 644.2 7218.9 99886.0 27.6 7218.9 100252.0 50.6 7214.3 99937.0 32.0 7252.2 113534.0 973.7 7201.2 99914.0 26.9 7206.0
hc12p-p 448002.0 3407.6 7201.0 243421.0 234.2 7200.1 245175.0 284.2 7290.0 236428.0 37.5 7210.8 236717.0 43.2 7200.7 236496.0 37.8 7208.0 235971.0 9.1 7200.1 236539.0 40.5 7213.6
hc12u-p 4095.0 3222.9 7201.0 2336.0 238.1 7199.6 2386.0 382.2 7198.2 2262.0 18.9 7206.3 2265.0 27.5 7200.8 2263.0 24.1 7206.0 2271.0 30.4 7200.1 2262.0 23.4 7205.8
cc12-2p-p 861854.0 6188.4 7201.0 124844.0 230.3 7199.8 123920.0 186.5 7196.0 123838.0 166.6 7244.4 123838.0 164.1 7240.8 123838.0 165.7 7250.9 121273.0 31.7 7200.0 124646.0 221.3 7200.8
cc12-2u-p 8361.0 6186.4 7201.0 1210.0 206.2 7199.5 1211.0 213.3 7193.6 1187.0 65.5 7418.5 1185.0 54.5 7417.0 1187.0 65.8 7430.9 1177.0 16.7 7200.1 1198.0 129.4 7200.9
cc12-2n-p 654.0 429.9 7201.0 621.0 83.9 7198.9 625.0 131.8 7207.1 618.0 45.4 7276.7 619.0 51.8 7268.8 618.0 42.9 7271.3 615.0 7.8 7200.0 618.0 58.3 7218.5
cc3-12n-p 111.0 0.0 7201.0 112.0 67.3 7199.9 112.0 67.3 7217.4 111.0 0.4 7201.0 111.0 0.4 7200.3 111.0 0.4 7210.4 111.0 1.7 263.9 111.0 0.4 7200.7
cc3-12p-p 19630.0 280.7 7200.0 19646.0 290.6 8853.7 19646.0 290.4 7195.5 18957.0 37.6 7200.8 18967.0 42.2 7200.4 18942.0 34.1 7201.5 18997.0 283.1 7200.0 18871.0 11.7 7200.6
cc3-12u-p 193.0 298.5 7201.0 191.0 229.8 7199.1 191.0 229.9 7215.3 185.0 0.4 7202.4 185.0 0.5 7200.3 185.0 0.4 7202.4 187.0 79.3 432.5 185.0 0.4 7204.2
bipa2p-p 35768.0 87.8 7201.0 35922.0 132.3 53373.6 36144.0 202.8 43658.8 35364.0 12.2 7201.3 35347.0 8.2 7200.4 35364.0 11.9 7201.0 35333.0 8.4 7200.1 35347.0 8.1 7200.7
bipa2u-p 344.0 146.6 7202.0 349.0 257.1 53054.1 349.0 268.4 39829.3 338.0 25.8 7201.0 337.0 4.7 7200.5 337.0 4.4 7201.0 338.0 21.7 1614.5 337.0 4.8 7200.5
2r211c-p 97000.0 594.0 7200.0 89000.0 1.6 1421.8 89000.0 1.1 15820.8 89000.0 0.3 640.0 89000.0 0.5 470.7 89000.0 0.3 786.6 91000.0 159.9 938.4 89000.0 0.4 7200.1
wrp3-83-p 8901813.0 486.6 7211.0 8300925.0 3.8 7199.8 8300924.0 3.8 7196.2 8300909.0 0.1 7202.2 8300909.0 0.1 7201.2 8300908.0 0.1 7201.3 8301274.0 0.5 2809.0 8300910.0 0.1 7201.0
w23c23-p 693.0 41.6 7202.0 693.0 45.0 7200.0 699.0 103.7 7195.4 689.0 0.4 69.4 689.0 0.5 68.0 689.0 0.4 72.4 694.0 52.1 126.6 689.0 0.4 68.7
rc09-p -- 7200.0 7200.0 112084.0 99.5 7199.1 112742.0 153.5 7216.4 111005.0 2.0 1820.1 111005.0 2.9 1825.3 111005.0 2.8 1919.6 122536.0 761.3 7200.0 111005.0 2.6 1769.7
rt05-p -- 7200.0 7200.0 52790.0 307.9 7226.1 52430.0 261.6 7196.1 51573.0 31.6 7250.3 51635.0 47.6 7223.6 51497.0 20.8 7223.9 59216.0 956.7 7200.1 51749.0 55.5 7205.5
G106ac-p 151634246.0 5446.9 7203.0 37171997.0 847.4 7198.8 37174629.0 846.6 7284.2 36922003.0 173.3 7468.6 36921050.0 1.4 7405.6 36921035.0 116.2 7477.2 40839837.0 941.1 7201.8 36922647.0 1.7 7205.6
I064ac-p 408901305.0 3909.9 7464.0 186905250.0 390.2 7240.6 186915954.0 390.0 7194.1 186850690.0 0.6 7268.3 186851191.0 0.8 7262.9 186853328.0 0.8 7274.1 189008219.0 191.6 7200.7 186856940.0 0.9 7201.8
s5-p 36414.0 2215.3 7205.0 25210.0 325.9 7196.4 25210.0 327.8 7197.1 25210.0 2.6 51.3 25210.0 2.3 46.8 25210.0 2.6 57.3 25210.0 56.2 186.6 25210.0 2.2 46.8